About Us

Bingenheimer's Baked Goods began long before it became a business.

More than 50 years ago, Brenda "Nana" Bingenheimer started baking cookies for her husband Allen "Pappy" Bingenheimer when they lived on the farm. Ever since then, the family has been baking cookies together as a tradition. Over the years, we perfected recipes, filling the home with the smell of freshly baked cookies and creating memories that would last for generations.

As our family grew, so did the collection of recipes. We would always bake classics like Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, and Sugar Cookies for family gatherings at during the holidays.

For decades, those cookies were shared only with family, friends, neighbors, and church gatherings. People began to ask more and more frequently if we could bake for them, but it wasn't until 2024 that we decided to take a leap of faith and officially launch Bingenheimer's Baked Goods.

After licensing our family kitchen, we began offering our homemade cookies to the public on April 1, 2024. Our family tradition quickly grew into something much bigger than we ever imagined. Today, you can order anytime from our website, you can find us in local stores, schedule us for a fundraiser, and our 40+ flavors of cookies travel every week in our cookie trailer.

Every cookie we bake is still inspired by the values our family was built on—faith, hard work, quality, and treating people like family. Many of our recipes are based off of the same ones Nana started 50+ years ago, while others are new creations inspired by family favorites or customer requests.

What makes Bingenheimer cookies special isn't just the recipes, its the family history and people behind them. The cookies are still baked out of Nana and Pap's home, and the family works together to provide freshly baked happiness to everyone.

When you purchase from Bingenheimer's Baked Goods, you're not buying from a large corporation. You're supporting a family that believes homemade still matters.

Thank you for allowing us to share a little piece of our family's story with yours.

From our family to yours,

The Bingenheimer Family